Sanatana Dharma, also known as Hinduism, is a rich and diverse tradition that encompasses various philosophical, religious, and cultural aspects of life. Among its most celebrated and revered texts are the two great epics, Ramayana and Mahabharata, which narrate the heroic deeds and ethical dilemmas of ancient kings, sages, warriors, and gods. These epics are not mere stories of historical events, but rather profound expressions of the eternal principles and values that guide the followers of Sanatana Dharma. In this article, we will explore the ethical dimensions of the wars depicted in Ramayana and Mahabharata, and unveil the ethical principles that shaped the epic battles.
Ramayana: Confronting Ravana, the Outsider King
The Ramayana is a Sanskrit epic composed by the sage Valmiki, probably between the 7th and 4th centuries BCE. It tells the story of Rama, the prince of Ayodhya, who is exiled for 14 years along with his wife Sita and his brother Lakshmana. During their exile, Sita is abducted by Ravana, the king of Lanka, who is a powerful and tyrannical demon. Rama, with the help of his loyal friend Hanuman and an army of monkeys and bears, wages a war against Ravana to rescue Sita and restore the cosmic order.
The war between Rama and Ravana is not a simple conflict between good and evil, but rather a complex and nuanced ethical war that involves various factors and perspectives. Ravana is not a mere villain, but a learned and accomplished ruler who has mastered the Vedas, the sacred scriptures of Sanatana Dharma. He is also a devotee of Shiva, one of the supreme deities of Hinduism. However, he is also arrogant, lustful, and oppressive, who violates the moral codes of dharma by abducting another man’s wife and tormenting his subjects. Rama, on the other hand, is not a flawless hero, but a human being who faces doubts, dilemmas, and challenges in his quest to uphold dharma. He is an ideal son, husband, brother, and king, who follows the principles of truth, non-violence, self-control, and compassion. However, he also makes mistakes, suffers losses, and struggles to balance his personal and social duties.
The ethical practices during the war reflect the values and norms of Sanatana Dharma, which prescribe the rules of conduct for righteous warfare. These rules include respecting the enemy, avoiding unnecessary violence, protecting the innocent, honoring the agreements, and seeking peace and reconciliation. The war is not a mere physical combat, but a spiritual and moral test for both sides, who have to face their own weaknesses and strengths. The war also involves the intervention of divine forces, who support or oppose the warring parties according to their adherence to dharma. The war is ultimately a manifestation of the cosmic conflict between the forces of order and chaos, which is resolved by the triumph of dharma over adharma.
The treatment of war victims and its ethical implications reveal the compassion and justice of Sanatana Dharma, which recognize the dignity and divinity of all living beings. The war causes immense suffering and destruction, which affects not only the combatants, but also the civilians, animals, and nature. The war also results in the death of many noble and heroic characters, such as Jatayu, the vulture who sacrifices his life to protect Sita, and Lakshmana, Rama’s loyal brother who is fatally wounded by Ravana’s son Indrajit. The war also exposes the flaws and faults of some characters, such as Vibhishana, Ravana’s brother who defects to Rama’s side, and Sita. The war also reveals the grace and mercy of Sanatana Dharma, which offer forgiveness and redemption to those who repent and reform. The war ends with Rama killing Ravana, but not before honoring him as a worthy adversary and a learned scholar. Rama also restores Vibhishana as the rightful king of Lanka, and reunites with Sita after accepting her purity and innocence.
Mahabharata: Internal Strife within the Family Dynasty
The Mahabharata is another Sanskrit epic composed by the sage Vyasa, probably between the 4th and 3rd centuries BCE. It narrates the story of the Kurukshetra War, a war of succession between two branches of the Kuru clan, the Pandavas and the Kauravas, who are cousins and rivals. The Pandavas are the five sons of Pandu, who are Yudhishthira, Bhima, Arjuna, Nakula, and Sahadeva. They are also the husbands of Draupadi, the daughter of Drupada, the king of Panchala. The Kauravas are the 100 sons of Dhritarashtra, who are led by Duryodhana, the eldest and the most wicked. The war is triggered by the greed and envy of Duryodhana, who cheats the Pandavas of their rightful share of the kingdom in a rigged dice game, and insults and humiliates Draupadi in public. The war is also influenced by the divine plan of Krishna, the incarnation of Vishnu, who is the friend and guide of the Pandavas.
The war between the Pandavas and the Kauravas is not a clear-cut conflict between right and wrong, but rather a tragic and complex ethical war that involves various emotions and motivations. The Kauravas are not entirely evil, but a mixed bag of characters who have different shades of morality. Some of them, such as Duryodhana, Dushasana, Shakuni, and Karna, are driven by ambition, hatred, deceit, and revenge, who violate the principles of dharma by oppressing the Pandavas and abusing Draupadi. Others, such as Bhishma, Drona, Kripa, and Ashwatthama, are bound by loyalty, duty, gratitude, and honor, who fight for the Kauravas despite knowing their injustice and wickedness. The Pandavas are not wholly virtuous, but a diverse group of characters who have different personalities and flaws. Some of them, such as Yudhishthira, Arjuna, and Nakula, are righteous, courageous, and generous, who follow the principles of dharma by seeking justice and peace. Others, such as Bhima, Sahadeva, and Draupadi, are aggressive, proud, and vengeful, who sometimes deviate from the principles of dharma by resorting to violence and deception.
The ethical practices during the war reflect the values and norms of Sanatana Dharma, which prescribe the rules of conduct for righteous warfare. These rules include respecting the enemy, avoiding unnecessary violence, protecting the innocent, honoring the agreements, and seeking peace and reconciliation. However, these rules are often violated or compromised by both sides, who resort to unfair and unethical means to gain advantage or survival. The war is not only a physical combat, but a psychological and moral test for both sides, who have to face their own dilemmas and conflicts. The war also involves the intervention of divine forces, who support or oppose the warring parties according to their adherence to dharma. The war is ultimately a manifestation of the cosmic conflict between the forces of order and chaos, which is resolved by the triumph of dharma over adharma.
The treatment of war victims and its ethical implications reveal the compassion and justice of Sanatana Dharma, which recognize the dignity and divinity of all living beings. The war causes immense suffering and destruction, which affects not only the combatants, but also the civilians, animals, and nature. The war also results in the death of many noble and heroic characters, such as Abhimanyu, the son of Arjuna, who is killed by a joint attack of six warriors, and Ghatotkacha, the son of Bhima, who is slain by Karna’s divine weapon. The war also exposes the flaws and faults of some characters, such as Yudhishthira, who lies to Drona about the death of his son Ashwatthama, and Arjuna, who hesitates to kill his own relatives and teachers. The war also reveals the grace and mercy of Sanatana Dharma, which offer forgiveness and redemption to those who repent and reform. The war ends with the Pandavas defeating the Kauravas, but not before performing the last rites for their enemies and honoring them as their kinsmen. The Pandavas also rule the kingdom with righteousness and benevolence, and eventually renounce it to attain liberation.
Ethical Practices Learnings
The lessons from facing inside and outside enemies in both epics are manifold and profound, which can be applied to personal and societal conflicts. The epics teach us that the enemies are not always external, but sometimes internal, who can be our own relatives, friends, or even ourselves. The epics also teach us that the enemies are not always evil, but sometimes good, who can be our own teachers, mentors, or role models. The epics also teach us that the enemies are not always different, but sometimes similar, who can share our own blood, culture, or religion. The epics also teach us that the enemies are not always enemies, but sometimes allies, who can help us grow, learn, or evolve.
The epics also teach us that the ethical teachings of Sanatana Dharma are not always rigid, but sometimes flexible, who can adapt to the changing circumstances and situations. The epics also teach us that the ethical practices of Sanatana Dharma are not always easy, but sometimes difficult, who can challenge our convictions and values. The epics also teach us that the ethical outcomes of Sanatana Dharma are not always favorable, but sometimes unfavorable, who can cause us pain and loss. The epics also teach us that the ethical victories of Sanatana Dharma are not always worldly, but sometimes spiritual, who can lead us to liberation and bliss.
The relevance of dharma in contemporary ethical dilemmas is undeniable and vital, which can help us navigate the complex and diverse issues that we face in our personal and professional lives. The epics show us that dharma is not a fixed or static concept, but a dynamic and evolving one, which can vary according to time, place, and situation. The epics also show us that dharma is not a single or monolithic principle, but a multifaceted and holistic one, which can encompass various aspects of morality, duty, law, and justice. The epics also show us that dharma is not a personal or individual matter, but a social and universal one, which can affect the well-being of ourselves, others, and the environment. The epics also show us that dharma is not a human or mundane affair, but a divine and cosmic one, which can reflect the will and purpose of the supreme reality.
Ethical Principles Paving the Path to Victory in the War of Dharma
The examination of the strategic adherence to ethical principles reveals the importance and influence of righteousness in both epics, which can determine the success or failure of the warring parties. The epics demonstrate that the adherence to ethical principles is not a matter of convenience or expediency, but a matter of commitment and integrity, which can require sacrifice and courage. The epics also demonstrate that the adherence to ethical principles is not a matter of weakness or naivety, but a matter of strength and wisdom, which can confer power and protection. The epics also demonstrate that the adherence to ethical principles is not a matter of isolation or alienation, but a matter of connection and collaboration, which can attract support and assistance. The epics also demonstrate that the adherence to ethical principles is not a matter of chance or luck, but a matter of destiny and grace, which can align with the divine plan and favor.
The analysis of how righteousness influenced the outcomes reveals the consequences and rewards of following or violating dharma in both epics, which can shape the fate and fortune of the warring parties. The epics illustrate that the violation of dharma can lead to negative outcomes, such as defeat, death, dishonor, and misery, which can affect not only the violators, but also their associates and dependents. The epics also illustrate that the following of dharma can lead to positive outcomes, such as victory, life, honor, and happiness, which can affect not only the followers, but also their allies and beneficiaries. The epics also illustrate that the outcomes of dharma are not always immediate or apparent, but sometimes delayed or hidden, which can require patience and faith. The epics also illustrate that the outcomes of dharma are not always material or temporal, but sometimes spiritual or eternal, which can transcend the worldly realm and attain the highest goal.
The enduring impact of ethical victories on Sanatana Dharma is immense and profound, which can inspire and guide the followers of Sanatana Dharma for generations to come. The epics reveal that the ethical victories are not mere historical events, but rather timeless and universal truths, which can resonate with the human condition and aspiration. The epics also reveal that the ethical victories are not mere personal achievements, but rather collective and communal contributions, which can benefit the society and the world. The epics also reveal that the ethical victories are not mere human endeavors, but rather divine manifestations, which can reveal the glory and grace of Sanatana Dharma. The epics also reveal that the ethical victories are not mere ends, but rather means, which can pave the way for the ultimate victory of liberation and bliss.
Comparative Analysis
The common ethical threads between Ramayana and Mahabharata are numerous and significant, which can highlight the core and essential values of Sanatana Dharma. Both epics share the theme of dharma, which is the central and overarching concept that governs the ethical actions and decisions of the characters. Both epics also share the theme of karma, which is the law of cause and effect that determines the ethical outcomes and consequences of the actions. Both epics also share the theme of bhakti, which is the devotion and surrender to the supreme reality that guides and supports the ethical endeavors and achievements of the characters. Both epics also share the theme of moksha, which is the liberation and bliss that results from the ethical victories and fulfillment of the characters.
The differences in ethical considerations and outcomes are also evident and relevant, which can reflect the diversity and complexity of Sanatana Dharma. The Ramayana depicts a more straightforward and clear-cut ethical war, where the distinction between right and wrong, friend and foe, and victory and defeat is more apparent and definite. The Mahabharata depicts a more complicated and ambiguous ethical war, where the distinction between right and wrong, friend and foe, and victory and defeat is more subtle and uncertain. The Ramayana depicts a more external and objective ethical war, where the enemy is an outsider who threatens the cosmic order and harmony. The Mahabharata depicts a more internal and subjective ethical war, where the enemy is a relative who challenges the family bond and loyalty. The Ramayana depicts a more optimistic and positive ethical war, where the outcome is a happy and harmonious reunion and restoration. The Mahabharata depicts a more pessimistic and negative ethical war, where the outcome is a tragic and sorrowful loss and destruction.
The unifying principles that transcend both epics are profound and sublime, which can reveal the ultimate and supreme reality of Sanatana Dharma. Both epics affirm the principle of Brahman, which is the absolute and infinite reality that pervades and transcends the entire creation and manifestation. Both epics also affirm the principle of Atman, which is the true and eternal self that resides and shines in the heart of every being. Both epics also affirm the principle of Maya, which is the illusory and relative power that projects and conceals the reality of Brahman and Atman. Both epics also affirm the principle of Lila, which is the playful and mysterious expression of Brahman that manifests and dissolves the reality of Maya.
Facts and Outcomes of the Scripts Written by Rishis and Nobles
The Ramayana and the Mahabharata are two of the most ancient and revered texts of Sanatana Dharma, which have been composed by rishis and nobles who were inspired by the divine revelation and the historical events. The facts and outcomes of the scripts written by these authors can be validated by various sources, such as the Vedas, the Upanishads, the Puranas, the commentaries, the regional versions, the archaeological evidence, and the literary analysis.
The Vedas are the oldest and the most authoritative scriptures of Sanatana Dharma, which contain the hymns, rituals, and philosophy of the Vedic religion. The Ramayana and the Mahabharata are derived from the Vedas, as they contain many references and quotations from the Vedic texts. For example, the Ramayana mentions the names of the Vedic gods, such as Indra, Agni, Varuna, and Surya, who are invoked and praised by the characters. The Mahabharata also mentions the names of the Vedic sages, such as Vashishtha, Vishwamitra, Bharadvaja, and Vyasa, who are the ancestors and the teachers of the characters. The Vedas also provide the ethical and moral framework for the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, as they define the concept of dharma, which is the righteous and moral way of living. The Vedas also provide the cosmological and metaphysical framework for the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, as they describe the creation and the dissolution of the universe, the cycles of time, and the nature of the supreme reality.
The Upanishads are the philosophical and mystical texts that are considered as the essence and the culmination of the Vedas. The Ramayana and the Mahabharata are influenced by the Upanishads, as they contain many teachings and doctrines from the Upanishadic texts. For example, the Ramayana illustrates the concept of the Atman, which is the true and eternal self that resides in the heart of every being. The Ramayana also illustrates the concept of the Brahman, which is the absolute and infinite reality that pervades and transcends the entire creation. The Mahabharata also illustrates the concept of the Maya, which is the illusory and relative power that projects and conceals the reality of Brahman and Atman. The Mahabharata also illustrates the concept of the Lila, which is the playful and mysterious expression of Brahman that manifests and dissolves the reality of Maya. The Upanishads also provide the spiritual and ethical guidance for the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, as they prescribe the methods and the goals of the spiritual quest, such as the meditation, the renunciation, the devotion, and the liberation.
The Puranas are the historical texts that narrate the stories and the legends of the gods, the sages, the kings, and the heroes of Sanatana Dharma. The Ramayana and the Mahabharata are related to the Puranas, as they contain many stories and characters that are also found in the Puranic texts. For example, the Ramayana narrates the story of Rama, who is the seventh incarnation of Vishnu, the supreme God in charge of the preservation of the universe. The Ramayana also narrates the story of Hanuman, who is the son of the wind god Vayu and the devotee of Rama. The Mahabharata narrates the story of Krishna, who is the eighth incarnation of Vishnu and the friend and guide of the Pandavas. The Mahabharata also narrates the story of Karna, who is the son of the sun god Surya and the friend and ally of the Kauravas. The Puranas also provide the historical and cultural context for the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, as they describe the geography and the chronology of the ancient kingdoms and the dynasties that are associated with the epic characters.
The commentaries are the explanatory and interpretive texts that are written by the scholars and the saints of Sanatana Dharma, who have studied and analyzed the Ramayana and the Mahabharata from various perspectives and traditions. The Ramayana and the Mahabharata are enriched by the commentaries, as they provide the deeper and broader meanings and implications of the epic texts. For example, the Ramayana has been commented upon by the Advaita Vedanta philosopher Adi Shankara, who explained the non-dualistic and monistic philosophy of the Ramayana. The Ramayana has also been commented upon by the Vaishnava saint Ramanuja, who explained the dualistic and devotional philosophy of the Ramayana. The Mahabharata has been commented upon by the Dvaita Vedanta philosopher Madhva, who explained the dualistic and realistic philosophy of the Mahabharata. The Mahabharata has also been commented upon by the Vedanta philosopher Vedavyasa, who explained the synthesis and harmony of the various philosophies of the Mahabharata. The commentaries also provide the critical and analytical insights for the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, as they examine the authenticity and the validity of the epic texts, and resolve the apparent contradictions and inconsistencies in the epic narratives.
The regional versions are the adaptations and translations of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata that are written in the various languages and dialects of India and other Asian countries, who have been influenced by the epic texts. The Ramayana and the Mahabharata are diversified by the regional versions, as they reflect the local and regional variations and innovations of the epic texts. For example, the Ramayana has been adapted and translated into Tamil by the poet Kamban, who added the elements of the Tamil culture and literature to the epic text. The Ramayana has also been adapted and translated into Thai by the king Rama I, who added the elements of the Thai culture and literature to the epic text. The Mahabharata has been adapted and translated into Telugu by the poet Nannaya, who added the elements of the Telugu culture and literature to the epic text. The Mahabharata has also been adapted and translated into Javanese by the poet Mpu Sedah, who added the elements of the Javanese culture and literature to the epic text. The regional versions also provide the popular and accessible expressions for the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, as they make the epic texts more relevant and appealing to the diverse and widespread audiences and readers of the epic texts.
The archaeological evidence is the material and physical remains and traces that are found in the sites and the places that are associated with the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, who have been identified and excavated by the archaeologists and the historians. The Ramayana and the Mahabharata are supported by the archaeological evidence, as they provide the tangible and concrete proofs and clues of the epic texts. For example, the Ramayana mentions the bridge that was built by Rama and his army to cross the ocean and reach Lanka, which is believed to be the the Rama Setu, a chain of limestone shoals that connects India and Sri Lanka. The Ramayana also mentions the city of Ayodhya, which is believed to be the birthplace and the capital of Rama, which is located in the state of Uttar Pradesh in India. The Mahabharata mentions the war that was fought in the Kurukshetra, which is believed to be the battlefield and the sacred place of the epic characters, which is located in the state of Haryana in India. The Mahabharata also mentions the city of Hastinapura, which is believed to be the capital and the residence of the Kuru clan, which is located in the state of Uttar Pradesh in India. The archaeological evidence also provides the historical and cultural validation for the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, as they confirm and corroborate the epic texts with the scientific and objective methods and data.
The literary analysis is the study and evaluation of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata that are done by the literary critics and the scholars, who have applied the various theories and approaches of the literary criticism and the literary studies. The Ramayana and the Mahabharata are enhanced by the literary analysis, as they provide the aesthetic and artistic appreciation and understanding of the epic texts. For example, the Ramayana has been analyzed by the structuralist critic A.K. Ramanujan, who explained the structure and the function of the epic text as a narrative and a discourse. The Ramayana has also been analyzed by the feminist critic Madhu Kishwar, who explained the role and the representation of the women characters in the epic text. The Mahabharata has been analyzed by the psychoanalytic critic Sudhir Kakar, who explained the psychology and the motivation of the epic characters as a reflection of the human mind and behavior. The Mahabharata has also been analyzed by the postcolonial critic Gayatri Spivak, who explained the power and the resistance of the epic text as a product and a critique of the colonial and the postcolonial contexts. The literary analysis also provides the creative and innovative interpretations and perspectives of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, as they explore and expand the epic texts with the new and the contemporary methods and insights.
Conclusion
The ethical insights from Ramayana and Mahabharata are invaluable and timeless, which can enrich and enlighten the followers of Sanatana Dharma and the seekers of truth. The epics show us the ethical principles and practices that can help us face and overcome the challenges and conflicts that we encounter in our personal and professional lives. The epics also show us the ethical outcomes and consequences that can shape and influence our fate and fortune in this world and beyond. The epics also show us the ethical victories and achievements that can inspire and guide us to attain the highest and ultimate goal of liberation and bliss. The epics also show us the ethical wisdom and grace that can reveal and connect us to the supreme and absolute reality of Sanatana Dharma.
The enduring wisdom embedded in Sanatana Dharma is universal and eternal, which can appeal and relate to the human condition and aspiration. Sanatana Dharma teaches us that the ethical war is not a mere physical or historical phenomenon, but a spiritual and existential one, which can involve our own inner and outer enemies and allies. Sanatana Dharma also teaches us that the ethical war is not a mere human or mundane affair, but a divine and cosmic one, which can reflect the will and purpose of the supreme reality. Sanatana Dharma also teaches us that the ethical war is not a mere end, but a means, which can lead us to the ultimate victory of liberation and bliss.
The call to apply these ethical lessons in contemporary life is urgent and vital, which can help us navigate the complex and diverse issues that we face in our personal and professional lives. We can learn from the epics how to uphold and follow dharma, which is the righteous and moral way of living. We can also learn from the epics how to understand and accept karma, which is the law of cause and effect that governs our actions and outcomes. We can also learn from the epics how to cultivate and express bhakti, which is the devotion and surrender to the supreme reality that guides and supports us. We can also learn from the epics how to aspire and achieve moksha, which is the liberation and bliss that results from the ethical victories and fulfillment.
RSS - Posts
